Shooting Macros Section 3 – The Math

by Peter Zack

  

tree-frog

Note: I hope some of the first two Macro sections has helped you understand equipment and shooting. As is the funny thing with a blog publishing setup, the articles are posted by date and you may be seeing the last part first. If so, go to Part 1 and Part 2 and then come back to this next section in the series, in which we will look at the math and magnification factors in a bit more detail. Also if you have a question or ideas for this or other articles, contact us here.

This stuff can sound a bit boring but for those that want to know how close they can get with a certain setup, we’ll have a look at the math here.

Macro fly

You can test it yourself: First you can approximate the magnification of any macro set-up with a little careful test and a ruler on the kitchen table. All you need to know is the width of the sensor of your camera. So a Pentax K20D has a sensor size of 23.4W x 15.6L (mm). Use a ruler with clear measurements in millimetres. Focus the camera/lens combination at full extension, sharply on the ruler with the sensor plane as parallel as you can (straight down). Take a picture of the ruler and open the shot on your computer. It’s a simple matter of counting the number of millimetres across the image. If you got 18mm then the magnification would be 1.3x (23.4 / 18). With a Canon EOS 40D, the sensor width is 22.2mm. Using the same result the magnification would be 1.23x (22.2 / 18). This is about the only way you could calculate the magnification of a reversed lens, a pair of lenses stacked and possibly some filter add on macro lenses to a standard lens.

Stacked lenses referred to here for example could be a 50mm lens mounted normally to the camera and then using a filter ring which couples another lens reversed on the first lens. Similar to reversing a lens directly to the camera but with even greater magnification.

Reversed lens with extension tubes: To calculate the magnification with a reversed lens and extension tubes, you first have to do the test above and get as accurate a measurement as possible of the reversed lens’s magnification.

The Pentax FA50mm f1.4 when reversed on a K20D (sensor size 23.4mm) is 35mm (using test above)
MR: (23.4 / 35) = 0.67x

Formula: Mm = MR + (Ex/FL)
Mm: magnification in macro
MR: magnification of the Lens reversed
FL: focal length of lens
Ex: length of extension tubes

If we used a 31mm Pentax K mount extension tube, mounted to the camera, mount the lens to that tube with a 49mm (filter) to K mount adapter, we have about 34mm of extension (tube + adapter). The Macro Magnification is 1.35x = 0.67 +(34/50)

Macro Dragonfly

Extension tubes or Bellows: To calculate the effect of a set of tubes you will first need the magnification specifications of the normal lens you will add to the tubes. (Not a macro lens)

Formula: Mm = ((ML x FL)+Ex) / FL
Mm: magnification in macro
ML: magnification of the Lens
FL: focal length of lens
Ex: length of extension tubes

So for the first example we’ll use the Canon EF 50mm f/1.4 USM which has a maximum magnification of 0.15x alone. We will add 62mm of extension tubes to this lens.

1.39 = ((0.15 x 50) + 62) /50 in other words the lens can achieve 1.39x life sized. So you will get a little better than life sized with this setup.

Stacking lenses: All you need here is a filter adapter to reverse one lens and mount it to the filter end of a primary lens.

Formula: Mm = F1 / FR
Mm: magnification in macro
F1: Focal length of first lens
FR: Focal length of reversed lens

Example calculation could be a 200mm lens mounted to the camera body in the normal fashion and a 50mm lens reversed to the 200mm lens.

4 = 200/50

It would appear that I have ignored probably the most obvious; a macro lens and extension tube/bellows combination. I can’t determine or find a satisfactory formula that gives accurate results. The reason is that a dedicated macro lens might be 100mm in normal mode but when extended, the focal range changes because the lens has essentially a helical extension tube built in. So the macro focal length might be 72mm for that particular lens. But lens suppliers do not publish that focal length change. Without that data, formulas are inaccurate. You should be able to use the formula for Extension tubes and Bellows above but the calculation could be off by as much as 30%.

Tele-converters: A TC and a conventional lens. If the lens has a magnification of 0.25 at minimum focus then the TC will multiply that close up ability by the magnification it was designed for (1.4x, 2x, 3x, etc.). I.e.: 0.25 x 2 = 0.5 magnification or 1:2 (half life sized).

P&S and Pro-sumer cameras: Finally a note on Point & Shoot cameras that can offer a different option and advantage to some people who like close-up shooting. The P&S disadvantage is that most do not shoot in RAW and the sensors can be small, so there may be more noise in the shots and less ability to crop a shot afterwards. But many bridge cameras overcome these limits very well. Both these styles of cameras use very small sensors (commonly 1/1.8″ or 1/1.25″) and so when the camera is listed as an equivalent lens of  450mm (in 35mm terms) it is really about a 77mm or 95mm focal length lens. The longer lens equivalent will give greater working distances and the smaller sensor increases the apparent DOF. A good and inexpensive option for many shooters.

Dragonfly macro

So what can you get after some practice and reading the 3 sections of this article? Grzegorz Cywicki of Zabierzów, Poland has some amazing macros to share, just click on the photo above to see a sample of his work—all the photos illustrating part 3 of this series, were taken by him. He uses a fairly basic setup. A sub $500 camera with a few different setups. A dedicated macro lens (Tamron 90mm f2.8) and extension tubes from 60 to 130mm. A 21mm extension tube and a Tamron 75-300mm zoom. Also a Tamron 75-300mm with Raynox DCR-250 which we discussed in the first section of this series.  He uses natural light whenever possible and also diffused flash, off camera with some shots and reflectors with others.

All the subjects are alive and you will notice water drops on some shots. He carries a spray bottle of cold water with him to slow the insects down. Other times he will shoot early in the morning when it’s cool and they move slower.

When asked about the incredible Dragonfly shots, Grzegorz simply said: “A key to success is to know how the dragonfly behaves. They fly around their own territory and almost always they come back to the same place. Usually, before I decide to take [the] pictures, I’m trying to observe them. As I know where dragonflies most often come back, I take [the] pictures.”

If you would like to contact  Grzegorz by email, please go to the contact page and we’ll forward his email address to you.

If you have any additional information you would like to add to this topic or have a question, Please leave a comment below or send us an email from the contact page.

Cheers and good shooting –Peter Zack

All photos section 1&2: ©Peter Zack.

All photos section 3: ©Grzegorz Cywicki.

Related posts:

  1. Shooting Macros Section 2 – The Small World
  2. Shooting Macros Section 1 – Equipment
  3. Photography + Math + Flickr = ?
  4. Shooting Sunrises and Sunsets.
  5. Shooting Weddings Part 2 – Equipment


Tags: , ,

  

26 Comments

  1. Using a spray bottle of cold water to slow the subjects down a little is a great Idea Usually I go out early morning I will have to give the spray bottle a go.

    • All 3 of these Macro articles have been clear and informative, though this last one is more technical due ot the increased level of math.

      Also, I am intrigues by the idea of spraying an insect with water to slow it down, although i must admit this is counter-intuitive: anything I have evr sprayed with water takes off like a jet. :) I will give it a try though! Thanks again for provding this excellent service for us!

  2. I just LOVE your site! There is so much great content. I’m so excited to have found you!

  3. Thanks Peter. It was after reading your articles that prompted me to take out my Macro lenses, (one of which I bought before Christmas that I never even took out of the box.) and will begin to see what I come up with. Thanks for tips and advice.

  4. Great article, Peter.
    Detailed and informative, but very practical as well.
    As others have mentioned, the spray bottle is a great idea, and the water droplets add another dimension to the macro photographs.

    Well done and thank you for sharing this knowledge with us.

  5. A very informative and well thought out article. Very helpful and really shows all the options for macro work. I learned a bit more about macro than I knew. Great work! I look forward to future articles from you.

  6. Thanks Peter, macro photography was a subject that I didn’t understand much until after reading your article. Very informative and great content.
    I don’t have a Macro lens but do have a set of closed up filter, now I need to go out and find some “bugs”! :)

  7. This is the new writing that I have yet read about. I have booked marked this article for the future reading. A good referene article for any macro shooters :)

  8. This is a very good series and should enable anyone with a camera and a minimum of experience to begin to enjoy the Macro World all around us that
    unfortunately not enough people get to experience. Hopefully these articles will in some way change that.
    Great stuff.

  9. Parts 1-3 – what a great way to spend a lunch break! I’ll be book-marking this site, as the info contained therein is a great resource. Thank you for sharing, Peter!

  10. Peter, nicely written articles. Thanks.

  11. Very nice series of articles! I just picked up my first macro lens, the SMC Pentax-M 100mm F4 Macro, and you’ve provided some excellent information to get me started.

  12. Great site and thanks for the lessons. I am preparing my macro setup for spring shooting. Is it possible to use DA lenses with PK extension tubes? The tubes do not have A contact. Is it possible to use DFA lenses with the same PK tubes?

    Thanks in advance.

    • Subho,

      You can use any Pentax lens with P/K extension tubes, but you will have to use stop-down metering to set the exposure. Of course, you also lose AF (if the lens has it).

  13. This series is a real gem!
    I couldn’t find a site that perfectly answered my macro questions nor clearly explained the various equipment, until I happened upon this one.
    Looking forward to reading other offerings from the site.
    It’s a definite keeper. Thanks!

  14. I’m glad so many enjoyed the series and also for the comments. Glad you found us. We’ll do our best to keep it interesting!

  15. Way cool! Some very valid points! I appreciate you writing this write-up
    plus the rest of the website is extremely good.

  16. Wow, incredible blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
    you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is excellent, as
    well as the content!

  17. Hello there! Would you mind if I share your blog with my myspace group?

    There’s a lot of people that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Thank you

  18. Hi there, always i used to check website posts
    here in the early hours in the dawn, since i enjoy to find out
    more and more.

  19. Quality content is the important to invite the users to go
    to see the web site, that’s what this web page is providing.

  20. Best herbal male enhancement pill can be described as a perfect
    alternative to other enhancement pills like Vi-ag-ra.
    Furthermore, its efficiency is incomparable that you
    can now get rid of the extenders or pumps that you use to lengthen your penis.
    A rather cheaper technique is tooth bleaching, in that a bleaching
    agent is applied to the teeth.

  21. Nice blog here! Also your web site lloads up fast!
    What host are you using? Can I geet your affiliate link
    to your host?I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  22. Howdy! I just would like to give an enormous thumbs up for the good data you might have right here on this
    post. I will probably be coming back to your blog for more soon.

  23. Hey there! I know this is kinda off topic but I’d figured I’d ask.
    Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest writing a blog post
    or vice-versa? My site addresses a lot of the same topics as yours and I feel we could greatly benefit from each other.

    If you are interested feel free to shoot me an
    email. I look forward to hearing from you! Superb blog by the way!

  24. I like to share knowledge that will I’ve accumulated through the 12 months to assist improve team overall performance.

Leave a Response